Henry, we aren't asking anyone to overrule the GM's decision - that ship has sailed and the ink has dried. We just want to know if the module was intended to go that way - mainly so that when any of us run it for another table we know whether or not the offers require a unanimous decision.
The player had an IC reason to be contrary (although it wasn't as strong a reason as some, it likewise wasn't illogical), but even after RPing for an hour trying to convince him, he didn't relent - and vs another PC no amount of persuasion skill can do anything. Our GM told me that the same thing happened to his table - a single PC preventing the rest of the party from agreeing to the offers and earning rewards, even though the PCs were successful in completed what had been asked of them.
So again, the question is whether or not this is intended - if its intended then that is great, but if it isn't intended then I don't want to perpetuate it when I run the module.
_________________ - Jacqualine Alicia C.
5e character: Ser Heidi val'Tensen, AKA Ser Adelheidis Sigrid val'Tensen of Moratavia
Last edited by Heidi val'Tensen on Wed May 24, 2017 10:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.
|