but not to kibosh anyone elses opinion.. its still open for debate

Of course, I just didn't want anyone to think it had been only Pedro's decision and that there was back and forth on the result.

John

To be honest, the errata on this subject is pretty much settled

Baring some huge issue I'm missing that is

so the net result is that is I have a fine fervidite weapon I'm only getting an extra +1 damage against people with an AR higher than 3 (plus some corner cases involving constructs and shields)?

That seems underwhelming...though you can always make a shield or armor out of it ...

uhhh no..... ?

so the benefits of a fine weapon = +1 damage

The Original benefits of Fervidite =
+1 damage AND +1 more damage vs av 3+

and instead of making those things stack
fervidite is now +2 damage and instead of being better vs AV 3+ is When used against constructs or when used to break an object these weapons ignore the first 5 points of AR/Hardness.

so slightly more specialized and slightly more powerful

Okay. Sorry. Saw Fervidite in the Q&A section ... but missed the later errata in the materials section. Makes sense now.

As a matter of layout you might want to think about dropping the Q&A section since it is incomplete and is otherwise covered clearly in the body of the errata?

Done