Paradigm Concepts
http://forums.paradigmconcepts.com/

5e Encoding a Spellbook
http://forums.paradigmconcepts.com/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=2527
Page 1 of 1

Author:  Southernskies [ Tue Feb 07, 2017 7:36 pm ]
Post subject:  5e Encoding a Spellbook

Having thoughts about something suitable to bring this over from 3.5e to 5e.
Oddly, the SRD and PH don't give a page count for written spells, so carrying over from older rules, I'm presuming 1 page per spell level.

Quote:
New Skill Use: Encode Spellbook
Requirements: Artisan Tools (Calligraphy Supplies)
Usage: To create an encoded spellbook, the Wizard (or Ritual Caster: Wizard) must already have copied the spell into their master book. He can then combine the spell with another written text (using double the pages, time and cost of "Replacing the Book", see Wizard sidebar) to conceal it from Harvesters (and other casters). This is written as a complete tome and spells can't be added to the encoded book later.

The Int (Investigation) DC to identify an encoded spellbook is: 10+Int+Proficiency (Calligraphy) and suffers Disadvantage until identified as a spellbook. This is set when the book is written (and may be much lower than the wizard's current ability).
The author can always prepare spells from the book, others must succeed in an Arcana skill check (using the above DC) to decipher and copy the spells (failure means loss of the scribing materials).


Example 1: Arianne Racine, a 5th level wizard (Int: 18, +3 proficiency and trained in Calligraphy tools), decides it is time to write a travelling spellbook. Her current book holds 25 spell levels (8 x 1st, 4 x 2nd, 3 x 3rd) after finding and copying a scroll of fireball. After 50 hours of work and 500gp in materials, she completes her 50 page treatise "Home Cooking in the Coryani Empire: Farm Recipes of the Plebians."
With a DC of 17 (10+4+3) to recognize it as a spellbook, it is unlikely to be recognized if her room is ransacked while adventuring.

Example 2: Bobo the clown, a 1st level wizard/4th level rogue (Int: 12, not proficient in Calligraphy tools) writes a book called "The Emperor's joke book". His current book only holds 6 spells, so only takes 12 hours and 120gp in materials. With only a DC of 11 (10+1), not only is it easy to detect as a spellbook, Coryani officials are likely to take offence at the jokes and drop him in the nearest prison.

Author:  Nierite [ Tue Feb 07, 2017 8:45 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: 5e Encoding a Spellbook

If all a spell is was a series of words that need to be recited, maybe. From a flavour perspective, I can see a lot of troubles encoding a spell book. How much of the book is arcane mathematics and glyphs that can't adequately be encoded? There may be components in a 'spell book' which cannot be masked, like 'encoding' a medical diagram of a human kidney as anything but a diagram of a kidney and still have it be informative, for example. If you disguise it as a horse, how do you 'uncode' it in such a way as to actually be useful?

Effectively slipping a dust-cover from a different book on yours seems probably the most effective way of 'distracting' from the book in my understanding of Arcanis magic (which, admittedly, is not complete due to lack of published material).

Author:  Dante [ Mon Jul 24, 2017 5:51 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: 5e Encoding a Spellbook

I read an interesting real-life history book about magic in the middle-ages which talked about actual encoding of spell books, and that's probably what led to Gygax's original concept of needing to cast Read Magic to read another wizard's spell book. The example given was a simple cipher, but it would be enough for someone glancing at it to not understand it. It wasn't complicated enough to hide the book as being something other than a book written in either a code or strange language. In Arcanis 5e, the new Linguistics skill would be a good way for encoding a book. (Though such books are likely to be unnecessary for any spellcasters in the final Arcanis 5e rules based on playtest documents so far.)

Author:  Southernskies [ Mon Jul 24, 2017 6:33 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: 5e Encoding a Spellbook

Nierite wrote:
If all a spell is was a series of words that need to be recited, maybe. From a flavour perspective, I can see a lot of troubles encoding a spell book. How much of the book is arcane mathematics and glyphs that can't adequately be encoded? There may be components in a 'spell book' which cannot be masked, like 'encoding' a medical diagram of a human kidney as anything but a diagram of a kidney and still have it be informative, for example. If you disguise it as a horse, how do you 'uncode' it in such a way as to actually be useful?

See Baden-Powell's 'butterfly' series of paintings for how to do it. He made detailed maps of military installations using this method.

Author:  toodeep [ Thu Jul 27, 2017 9:11 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: 5e Encoding a Spellbook

Does anyone in Arcanis use a spellbook since there are no wizards?

Author:  Southernskies [ Thu Jul 27, 2017 10:51 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: 5e Encoding a Spellbook

They don't seem to be required 'in the field' like AD&D wizards. However, both Elder and Eldritch casters seem to need a lot of 'research' time in the library/lab etc.

Much easier to keep them out of sight hidden when they can be left home.

Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC - 5 hours
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/