Nierite wrote:
The major flaw I see with that argument is twofold: How would Calmemnon open the Throne Room without the Keys of Man (most appear to still be lost), and what kind of power would he have to have to do this? Is it just charisma based, or what else could give him enough. . . ummmfff to stand up against a TRUE DRAGON?
According to the First Prophesy it includes the lines:
"And about his head floated twelve keys
that shall unlock that which it most craves."
Taken at face value, he has recovered the 12 Keys. As for their recovery, many could have been hidden in the DZV or he could have had agents collecting the few that had been found from where they lay.
As for the necessary power, given Calmemnon's description I would put him below a Valinor but above your average val in terms of raw power. If he's survived the DZV he has power, artifacts, allies or some combination of the above that would allow him to fight off the dragon. He could have the backing of Valinor without the Valinor being the Destroyer or pulling his strings. It's also possible that there is some weapon left over from the Valinor / Dragon Wars that could be used. Besides, in my postulations I didn't state that Cal killed or destroyed the Dragon. I said he saved the First City from it. There may be other ways to banish, imprison or convince it to go elsewhere that would allow for him to be hailed the Savior. For all we know he could be in league with the Dragon, and Cal's saving the city from him, part of the master plan. It depends on how powerful Cal is.
Besides, the line of the prophesy referring to the Dragon is:
"Nations will tremble across the lands
And even the mightiest shall be in danger
For even the Dragon shall fall before this
Stranger"
Fall doesn't necessarily mean killed or destroyed. If Cal eliminates the Dragon's threat, the Dragon has fallen.
With a sweep of his hat,
Paul